Paper 3

Please choose one of the following questions to answer. Please type out the question you are answering at the top of your paper. The paper should be 1,000-to-1,200 words and is due during session 18.

  1. What is personal fission? Is it the sort of process that we can survive? What does Parfit say about fission? Is he right? Why or why not?
  2. Williams breaks down a fission case into a number of steps. He argues that at no stage does it make sense to start thinking that the A-bodied person is no longer A. If you were to argue that at some stage it does makes sense to think that the A-bodied person is no longer A, which stage would you pick? How would you respond to Williams’ argument against the plausibility of this judgment?
  3. If you wish you can write on a paper topic from the second paper assignment that you did not already write about.
  4. If you’d like to write about something else, please consult with your TA.